← Back to blog

How can we tell if OpenAI is giving us good answers?

ai openai critical-thinking

As AI language models like ChatGPT become more prevalent in our daily work, a critical question arises: “Many of the answers look right but aren’t. What is a good strategy to evaluate what the bot tells us?”

This is one of the most important challenges when working with AI assistants. Outputs can appear credible and well-formatted while containing errors, outdated information, or complete hallucinations.

Why This Matters

AI models are trained on vast amounts of text data, but they:

  • Don’t have real-time access to current information
  • Can’t verify facts in real-time
  • May confidently present incorrect information
  • Don’t understand context the way humans do

Validation Strategies

1. Cross-Reference Critical Information

Never rely solely on AI for important decisions or facts. Verify key information through:

  • Official documentation
  • Multiple authoritative sources
  • Recent publications (check dates!)

2. Test the Code

If the AI generates code:

  • Actually run it
  • Write tests for it
  • Check edge cases
  • Review for security vulnerabilities

3. Look for Consistency

Ask the same question in different ways. Inconsistent answers are a red flag that the model might be uncertain or making things up.

4. Check for Specific Details

Vague, general answers might indicate the model doesn’t have specific knowledge. Look for:

  • Concrete examples
  • Specific version numbers
  • Actual API names and methods
  • Real-world use cases

5. Use Your Domain Expertise

The best validation is your own knowledge. If something feels off, it probably is. AI should augment your expertise, not replace it.

6. Verify Recent Information

AI models have knowledge cutoff dates. For anything time-sensitive:

  • Check official release notes
  • Consult current documentation
  • Look at recent commits or changelogs

Best Practices

  1. Treat AI as a starting point, not the final answer
  2. Always review and edit generated content
  3. Test everything in a safe environment first
  4. Document your sources when using AI assistance
  5. Stay skeptical - healthy skepticism prevents costly mistakes

Conclusion

AI tools like ChatGPT are incredibly powerful assistants, but they’re just that - assistants. The responsibility for accuracy and quality ultimately lies with us. Use AI to accelerate your work, but always apply critical thinking and proper validation.

Remember: if you wouldn’t trust a random person on the internet without verification, don’t trust an AI without it either.